Silva
would also
like to see more driveable short par-4s with a “Redan feel”
where
players “would have to bust a shot to reach the kick
slope
that would
help them
onto the green.” He also
says TPCs need
more “greens where
they don’t hit right
at the pin, but hit to
a spot and then let the
green
take it to the
hole.”
Most
TPCs have
been designed to fit the modern player’s target-golf approach. But
Fought believes unpredictability is what creates exciting
golf. “Why
should the
hole have to fit the player’s
shot?” he
asks. “The players
are concerned about
getting from point A to
point B in the least amount
of strokes. They don’t want
any
distractions and they
don’t want any
unpredictability.”
Fought
also says
TPCs need “a couple of places to watch three or four holes.
Having a
few little intimate spots is so interesting. Just
look at Amen
Corner
and
everything that goes on
there.”
“It
would be
cool if somebody could build a TPC where they could use natural
contours to fit the spectators in with natural features, so
that it’s
not this
constant series of dug-out holes
with
ridges up the sides,”
architect Dana Fry
adds.
“They are just
so overbuilt. They’re not
really places where I
would want
to
play golf. With few exceptions,
you’re
not going to learn a lot about
golf
design when you experience
them.”
Fry
floats an
intriguing idea: What if Bill Coore and Ben Crenshaw built a TPC?
“They
would probably build a course that wasn’t 7,500 yards,”
he says, “and they
would put some interesting green contours
in front
of the
players.”
But
could the
PGA Tour ever hand over design chores to some of the modern game’s
more
provocative designers? “I don’t know if they’re open-box
people,” Fry
concedes.
Still,
Weed
believes the tour has all the inspiration it needs to build more
intriguing
TPC courses in the future. “They need to just go
back to
those initial
three
[Sawgrass, Scottsdale,
River Highlands]
and see they had a
formula that worked
and set them apart,”
Weed says. “And they’d realize
that the concept was
phenomenal
and ahead of its
time.”